INFORMATION LITERACY
I’m back again for this week’s
blog post. It's the third blog post for my environmental science class and it is all about
information literacy. The directions were to find a news article pertaining to environmental
science and sort of analyze how reliable the source is and the information that
they are providing. I did a bit of searching and I found an article posted on
BBC News’ website that I believe is interesting and relevant to the blog
assignment. This article—titled “Sea level fears as Greenland darkens”—discusses
the worries that some scientists have had about the melting of the Greenland
ice sheet, which is about seven times the size of the United Kingdom. These
scientists have observed that the melting is in large part due to the growth of
algae within the ice sheet, which causes the ice to become darker, and the dark
spots of ice cannot reflect as much sunlight, causing these areas to melt
more quickly. The melting of the ice sheet is concerning because it will cause sea levels to rise, something that those near the coast should be especially worried about. Because the ice sheet is so large, it can have a major impact on all parts of the world if it melts too quickly.
Now, moving on to the reliability of the news article; I do believe that the source, for the most part, is a reliable one. The are several reasons that led me to believe this. The article comes from BBC News, which is a very popular news source in the United Kingdom. However, just because BBC is "popular" does not mean they are necessarily reliable. They do seem to be, by popular opinion, one of the less biased news sources that exist, though. They were also founded in 1922 (according to Wikipedia), which gives them 94 years of experience with broadcasting and reporting news to the general public. This factor, I would say, gives them a lot of credibility as a news source.
The main factor that leads me to believe that this source is reliable is the fact that the author of the article, David Shukman, spoke directly to the scientists involved in the study. For example, one of the first statements made by Shukman in the article is, "They say warmer conditions are encouraging algae to grow and darken the surface." He then supports this statement with a direct quote from a glacial microbiologist, Dr. Joe Cook, someone who is actually on location studying the ice sheet: '"This is an extremely difficult place for anything to live but, as we look around us, all this darkness we can see on the ice surface is living - algae, microbes, living and reproducing in the ice sheet and changing its colour."' So, David Shukman makes several claims in this article, but he is able to support them all through information that he has gathered directly from the scientists who have made these discoveries about the melting ice sheet.
Shukman is made to seem even more reliable because he actually visited the scientists on location in Greenland as they were conducting the study, giving him a firsthand account of all the information that he provides within his article. He is shown on location in this video:
Although the video is humorous, it is also informational and it proves that the author, Shukman, was able to actually receive information all about this study directly from the scientists involved with it.
Overall, I was impressed with this article, because it was incredibly informative and the author really seemed to give an unbiased account of the work being done to find out more about the algae growing on the ice sheet. Although I found this article very interesting, I was mostly concerned by the information that I discovered within it. The potential, rapid melting of the ice sheet in Greenland could have a negative impact on many parts of the world, and it is due to warmer climate, most likely caused by climate change. It is extremely concerning, and I hope, through all the research that is done, we will find a way to do something to change the state of things.
Sources:
MAIN ARTICLE: http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-40686984
BBC Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC
Ice Sheet photo: https://www.csmonitor.com/Science/2016/0113/Greenland-s-melting-ice-sheet-a-breakthrough-in-understanding
Youtube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n8QWEfUzVgA&ab_channel=BBCNews




